Monday, May 16, 2016

Wesdome Gold Mines - The Battle Has Just Started

Wesdome Gold Mines is a small gold producer. The company operates two mines, located in the Mishibishu Greenstone Belt, Ontario, Canada. Mishibishu is part of a much larger mineral structure, called the Abitibi Greenstone Belt. Those familiar with world deposits surely know that Abitibi is one of the best gold-bearing areas, where many successful mining companies operate. One of such companies is Richmont Mines, operating its Island Gold Mine, located also in Ontario. To be honest, in my opinion, Wesdome is very similar to Richmont:

  • similar location (Abitibi Greenstone Belt)
  • similar deposit structure - quartz veins
  • both mines demonstrate the high-grading ores
  • last exploration programs delivered promising discoveries - levels 300 and 700 at Eagle River (Wesdome) and Lower Zone at Island Gold (Richmont)
  • both mines are in their transition periods, ramping-up production from new discoveries
  • both companies forecast much higher production in the coming years
Of these two companies it was Richmont which, most recently, delivered outstanding returns for its investors (the author of this blog included). Wesdome was a laggard. 
Well, I think that Wesdome is a sort of an outsider - not many investors are even aware of its existence. In my opinion, it is a mistake because Wesdome or, more precisely, its Eagle River Mine, is a very, very decent deposit. 

However, in 1Q 2016 the company delivered very poor results. Let me show just one chart:


Since 1Q 2015 the company was on track to decrease its production costs (represented by all-in sustaining costs) from C$1,971 to C$1,387 per ounce of gold. Then, suddenly, in 1Q 2016 these costs went strongly up to C$2,505 (an increase of 80.6% in just one quarter!). Well, I was very surprised. What is more, one of the largest Wesdome shareholders, Resolute Performance Fund, today announced that it initiated the action against the current company's management. Let me cite an abstract from this announcement:


"Resolute is particularly concerned with:

• the fact that gold production dropped to 8,036 ounces in the first quarter of 2016 
from 14,484 ounces in the third quarter of 2015;
• the significant increase in cash burn in the first quarter of 2016, as reflected by the 
decrease of $7.3 million in cash and cash equivalents, compared to a decrease of 
$0.362 million in the third quarter of 2015;
• the significant increase in the all-in sustaining costs per ounce on a production
basis to $2,501 per ounce in the first quarter of 2016, compared to $1,368 per
ounce in the third quarter of 2015; and
• the proposed increase in the size of the board of directors from five to eight
members, which Resolute believes will simply increase overhead and other costs
without leading to the necessary operational changes."


But the "best" part is here:


"Resolute does not believe that the proposed board and existing management are capable of addressing the pressing issues at Eagle River."


Well, Wesdome management got a very strong message. It looks like the battle of Wesdome has just started.

To be honest, I think that Resolute announcement confirms the fact that Eagle River is an excellent deposit. What is more, I do not think that Resolute action was ignited by the last quarter results. It  looks like the matter is much deeper and I expect that in the coming future we will get more info on this issue.

Summarizing - in my opinion, Resolute action against the current company's management is a starting point for the Eagle River takeover. Expect hot news on that issue soon. 



Sunday, May 15, 2016

Both Gold And Silver Are Still Far From A Bullish Frenzy

A few days ago The World Gold Council released its report, called "Gold Demand Trends". Although some people are declared critics of these reports, in my opinion, World Gold Council publications are always worth reading.

I do not want to go very deeply into this report but let me show just one chart:



source: Simple Digressions and the World Gold Council

The chart shows the difference between the gold demand and its supply. For clarity, I have plotted the average quarterly figures.

The chart explains that it was the increased demand that was standing behind the last rally in gold. According to the World Gold Council, in 1Q 2016 gold demand was 1,286.4 tons while supply was 1,134.9 tons. As a result, demand was higher than supply by 151.5 tons. 

I think it is good news for gold bugs. The similar situation happened in 2008 (demand higher than supply by 65.8 tons per quarter) and in 2010, 2011 and 2012. Each time demand was higher than supply the gold prices were in their upward trends. 

Another fact - it looks like the last rally may be the beginning of a new bull market phase in gold. In 2013, 2014 and 2015 each rally in gold prices was a short-term event during the downward trend. Note that in that period demand was lower than supply - simply put, gold was not supported by fundamentals. 

In 1Q 2016 it was different - the rally was supported by gold fundamentals.


Further, it looks like many analysts are warning of incoming severe correction in gold prices. While it may be the case (nobody knows the future), I see it a little bit differently. In my opinion, there is still no excessive optimism in gold and silver markets. Let me show these two charts (according to the COT Report):

Chart 1



Chart 2

The charts show the ratio of long positions / short positions, held by speculators in silver and gold futures contracts. The excessive optimism is marked by red arrows on Chart 1. 

In the case of silver, we may talk about a bullish frenzy when the ratio is over 12 (for example, on November 23, 2010, speculators were holding total long position in silver futures contracts of 48,870; their total short position was standing at 3,222 contracts so the ratio was 15.2).

In the case of gold a frenzy is when this ratio stands at above 7.

Today neither gold nor silver are even close to their frenzy ratios.

Friday, May 13, 2016

Richmont Mines Delivers Excellent 1Q 2016 Results

Richmont Mines is one of my five stock picks included in my model precious metals miners portfolio. A few days ago the company released it 1Q 2016 results. Excellent results. Below you will find the summary of this report (the most important measures are marked with yellow color):



* - free cash flow is defined as cash flow from operations (as reported in financial statements) less expenditure on property, equipment, acquisitions etc.
** - cash flow from operations is defined as cash flow from operations (as reported in financial statements) less working capital issues


Note an increase in sales of 41.5% while the price of gold (realized) went up only 8.9%. It is an effect of much higher gold production and sales.

These excellent operating results (higher production at stable costs of production) had a tremendous positive impact on cash flow from operations (an increase of 120%), EBITDA (up146%) etc.

I am sure that my readers know that the main factor standing behind these results is the Island Gold Mine. Currently the company is going into deeper levels of Island Gold (below 400 meters). The ore there is of much better quality. For example, between 2011 and 2014 Richmont was processing the ore from upper levels with head grades in the range of 4.63 - 6.10 grams per ton. 
In 2015, which was a transition year, the company was mining the ore grading 7.31 grams per ton, on average. In 1Q 2016 the average head grade was standing at 11.31 grams per ton! 
The chart below summarizes these figures:

Well, due to the fact that Island Gold is a dominant property in the company's mineral portfolio, its excellent performance should be driving the company's results higher in the coming years:


Summarizing - in my opinion, Richmont Mines is one of the best world miners. Its flagship property, Island Gold, is still open for exploration so investors should expect additional, good news on this deposit in the coming future. 

Additional note

It is a negative note. Richmont is a growing company. It means that it should deliver better and better results in the coming future. Of course, its shareholders should be happy - Richmont share prices go up. However, there is one class of stakeholders that benefits even more. What is more, in my opinion, this class gets too much. This class is the company's management: 



The chart above shows that the so-called "Share-based payments" account for around one third of total management compensation. Between 2010 and 2015 the company's management was paid C$32.6 million, of which as much as C$11.2 million was attributed to share-based payments (34.4% of total compensation). 

It is not usual. For example, Barrick Gold usually pays its managers not more than 5% of their compensation in share-based payments (2015 Annual Report, Note 32, page 163). Well, I understand that Richmont is a much smaller company than Barrick. It means it has less cash to pay its managers decently therefore the company pays them with stock options. However, it also means that, indirectly, the company's management is paid by Richmont shareholders - between 2010 and 2015 the management exercised 2,828 thousand stock options. In other words, because the current share count is 58,651 thousand, Richmont shareholders diluted their stake by around 5% in order to compensate the management. 

Thursday, May 12, 2016

Another Drilling Company Has More Work To Do

In my last article on Geodrill I have noted that West African drilling companies are doing quite well.

Yesterday another driller, Orbit Garant, released its 1Q 2016 report. Contrary to Geodrill, Orbit Garant offers its services mainly in Canada. 

However, similarly to Geodrill, Orbit also managed to increase the number of meters drilled:


The red arrow marks an uptrend in the number of meters drilled.

On the other hand, also similarly to Geodrill, the pricing power is still at Orbit's customers:


Although the company has more work to do, it gets less money for each meter drilled ($65.2 per one meter in 1Q 2016).

I would say - there are the first symptoms of a revival (more work) but the industry is still far away from a boom (low prices). 

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Drilling Companies - Very Low Valuations

In addition to the last article on Geodrill, below I have plotted two charts showing the current valuations of a few drilling companies:



According to the chart above, using a multiple EV / EBITDA as a valuation measure, Geodrill and Swick were two strongly undervalued drilling companies.

On the other hand, using another metric, price to book value (P / BV), it looks like nearly all drillers are valued below their book values:

The only exception is Major Drilling, one of the biggest world drilling companies.



Tuesday, May 10, 2016

Geodrill - Yes, They Can!

A mineral drilling industry is in its cyclical slump. However, there is one company, which seems to be untouched by the problems encountered by its peers.

It is Geodrill. The company owns a fleet of 42 rigs, of which 37 are available for operations. Geodrill operates mainly in West African countries: Ghana, Mali, Burkina Faso and The Ivory Coast. 

My readers surely know that I am quite enthusiastic about West Africa. Despite some specific risks as, for example, the Ebola disease, these countries offer very decent conditions for mineral mining companies. Hence, a number of mining companies, mainly of Canadian origin, run very decent mining businesses there. And if there are active mines there is also the demand for drilling services in general and for Geodrill, in particular. Below I have enclosed the list of Geodrill clients, past and present: 




                                            source: Geodrill

As I noted above, despite the industry slump, Geodrill reports quite decent results. In 1Q 2016 the company was even profitable, reporting a small net income of $1.6 million. However, in my opinion, the most important thing is the fact that Geodrill has managed to increase the number of meters drilled:



                               source: Simple Digressions

As the chart shows, since 2014 Geodrill has been increasing the number of meters drilled. In 1Q 2016 the company broke its record, drilling 240.4 thousand meters, the highest number in its history. 

However, the prices obtained by Geodrill are still at their historical lows:


                                 source: Simple Digressions


It looks like there is the demand for drilling services but the conditions (prices) are set by the customers (mining companies).

Anyway, more meters drilled, even at low prices, means higher revenue and better financial results. For example, look at cash flow from operations (without working capital issues and taxes). For better clarity, I have plotted the average quarterly cash flows: 



                             source: Simple Digressions

Let me count one thing. $5 million a quarter means $20 million in annual cash flow from operations. Deduct from this cash flow:

  • $2 million in taxes
  • roughly $10 million in sustaining capital (to keep the company going)


and as much as $8 million is left for the company per year.

After discounting this figure by 10%, the business value (enterprise value) stands at $80 million. Because the company carries practically no net debt (cash = debt) the value of the business is equal to the market value of the company's stocks.

Today Geodrill shares are trading at $0.89 a share so the company's market value is $40 million. It looks like my quick valuation has disclosed that Geodrill is now 50% undervalued.








Monday, May 9, 2016

Endeavour Mining - The Old Question Marks Remain; One New Added

In my first article on Endeavour Mining I stated that there were too many question marks over the company. Let me remind them and add a few current observations:

One mine story

The company is a one mine story - of the four operating mines only Agbaou delivers decent results. Fortunately, in 1Q 2016 the Ity mine, the newest operation in the company's portfolio, also delivered quite a nice operating profit of $6,539 thousand:



I am very curious how this new mine will be performing in the future. Looking at 1Q 2016, I am becoming confident that it may be a very decent operation.


The Nzema mine

It is still a laggard. What is more, in 1Q 2016 its performance had even deteriorated - operating costs went up from $934 to $1,111 per ounce of gold sold (an increase of 19%):



Well, the main factors standing behind this poor performance were grades and recovery ratios:

As I noted in my last article, Nzema takes part of its ore from the third party. This ore is generally of better quality than the ore coming from Nzema. In 1Q 2016 the company was not able to bring a sufficient amount of the ore from the third party (only 7,819 ounces of gold were produced from the ore from outside; in 1Q 2015 it was 10,780 ounces). Hence, higher costs and worse results. 

Acquisition of True Gold

On April 26 the company announced the completion of the acquisition of True Gold. As a result, Endeavour has added a mine under construction, called Karma (located in Burkina Faso). 
My readers know that, in my opinion, Endeavour has overpaid for True Gold but I am very keen on getting more knowledge on Karma's performance. The data should be available very soon - Karma commercial production is expected in June.  

Hounde Project

Hounde is another project under construction and no new relevant events took place since my last article on Endeavour.


Current valuation metrics.

Similarly to the previous article, below I am putting a chart showing current valuations of a few African miners:





Summary

In my previous article on Endeavour Mining I did not recommend its shares as a buying opportunity. I sustain my stance on the company. In 1Q 2016 the company delivered more or less similar results as in 1Q 2015. Of the four operating mines, Agbaou showed decent results, Nzema performed worse than last year and the new mine, Ity, in my opinion, delivered very decent results. 
The other the so-called question marks (Karma, Hounde) are still unknowns. 

Additional note

Endeavour Mining mines are owned not only by the company. Other stakeholders, mainly the governments of resident countries, hold the following stakes:

  • Agbaou - 15%
  • Nzema - 10%
  • Tabakoto - 20%
  • Ity - 45%

And here is another problem. The best mines are Agbaou and Ity. Unfortunately, in the case of Ity, as much as 45% of net income, generated by this mine, goes to the other stakeholders; the company gets only 55% of the cake. It is not a nice info for the company's shareholders because one of its best mines delivers only a fraction of its earnings to Endeavour shareholders. 

On the other hand, 90% of Nzema loses is attributable to the company's shareholders. 

It means that one of the best mines delivers only 55% of its profits to Endeavour shareholders and the worst mine charges these shareholders with 90% of its loses. As a result, despite the fact that Endeavour 1Q 2016 net earnings were $11,131 thousand , only $4,054 thousand was attributable to the company's shareholders. 

It is another negative factor investors should remember when planning to invest in Endeavour Mining shares.